Reply To: The Quantum Cheshire Cat Experiment of Denkmayr et al

Mark Stuckey

The arXiv paper has been rewritten in the form it was just today submitted to New J Phys (where Aharonov published his quantum Cheshire Cat proposal and Correa et al. published their qCC paper). Yesterday, Nature Comm said they would not publish our Brief Communication Arising on the refutation because it’s based on an unpublished technical point (and so could not be conveyed in the 600-word limit of a BCA). Rather, they advised us to seek publication elsewhere of the full 15-page explanation of our claim — linear interaction is required to make the qCC inference from the weak values, i.e., quadratic interaction kills qCC. Here again is the link to the arXiv paper

Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.